Dr. Moira McCarthy, MD
Orthopedic Surgery*
15+ years of experience
Dr. Moira McCarthy, MD is an orthopedic surgeon in New York, NY and has over 15 years of experience in the medical field. Dr. McCarthy has extensive experience in Knee & Lower Limb Surgery. She graduated from Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons in 2008. She is affiliated with Stamford Hospital. She is accepting new patients and telehealth appointments.
4.4 Star Rating
Based on 20 reviews 4.4 Star Rating (20 reviews)
Practice
535 E 70th St New York, NY 10021Telehealth available
Make an Appointment
At a Glance
- Areas of ExpertiseDr. McCarthy specializes in the areas of Orthopaedic Sports Medicine & Orthopedic Surgery. • See board certifications
- Explains Conditions Well
- Offers TelehealthThis doctor offers telehealth appointments. Call the office to schedule an appointment.
- Clean Hospital
ADVERTISEMENT
Save money with free prescription discounts
Get your prescription for as low as $4 with our free coupons or discount card, usable at over 64,000 participating pharmacies.
Get your prescription for as low as $4 with our free coupons or discount card, usable at over 64,000 participating pharmacies.
Optum Perks and Healthgrades are subsidiaries of RVO Health.
Experience Check
Search for experience in a specific area
Insurance Check
Search for your insurance carrier and choose your plan type
Dr. McCarthy's Reviews
Likelihood to recommend Dr. McCarthy
4.4
20 ratings, 11 with a written review
| 5 star | 85% | 85% |
| 4 star | 0% | 0% |
| 3 star | 0% | 0% |
| 2 star | 0% | 0% |
| 1 star | 15% | 15% |
Your trust is our top concern.
We strive to keep reviews honest, trustworthy, and fair.Doctors can not pay for good reviews, nor can they pay to have negative reviews removed.
We monitor all reviews to ensure they comply with our guidelines and don’t include personal information, profanity, libel, defamation, harassment, obscenity or fraud.
Any reviews that are deemed fraudulent or violate our guidelines will be removed immediately.
All reviews are confirmed and audited before publication, and community members have the ability to flag inappropriate content for further review by our team.
Excellent
What went well
- I felt respected
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
1 other person found this helpful
Helpful
Mar 05, 2024
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
She is very knowledgeable, takes the time to explain all the options, and has wonderful staff who return phone calls and emails quickly. She stays focused on the patient's best interests.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
7 others found this helpful
Helpful
Dec 12, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
I had ACL surgery with a meniscus repair. Dr. McCarthy was incredibly thorough and explained everything so well. She doesn’t rush you in and out and is happy to answer any questions and help you understand the details regarding your injury and the details on what will be done during surgery as well as post surgery. I had a great experience! I’m recovering really well and I think a lot of that has to do with her expertise and how much she cares for her patients.
What went well
No results
What could be improved
No results
12 others found this helpful
Helpful
Apr 24, 2019
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Excellent!!
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
7 others found this helpful
Helpful
New York, NY – Oct 27, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Dr McCarthy fixed my ACL after my 54th birthday. The first doctor I saw said most folks my age don't get it fixed, and mildly discouraged me. Dr. McCarthy made sure she understood my goals, was extremely honest, and took as much time as I needed to discuss at each step. She listens well, radiates confidence, and has a dry but comforting sense of humor. 6 months out, I'm day-hiking 5 miles and feeling great. Recovery far less painful than repair to my other knee 14 years ago. A total pro.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
10 others found this helpful
Helpful
Jeff C. in NY – Oct 05, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Dr. Moira McCarthy is perhaps one of the best orthopedic sports specialists in NYC. She puts the interests of the patient first, listens and explains all of the options. She is a smart, impressive doctor and exudes a confidence in her diagnosis that is reassuring to the patient. Dr. McCarthy performed surgery on my 72 yr old left knee to repair two meniscus tears. The pain was immediately gone and while I have some OA issues, I have been back on the tennis courts. Dr. McCarthy knows knees!
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
10 others found this helpful
Helpful
Bernard McCrossan in NY, NY – Oct 04, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
A unique experience. Dr McCarthy was thorough, detailed and explained something twice when she wasn't sure I understood. She did not jump straight into a surgery like the first doctor I saw and she actually looked into my MRI - she didn't just read the MRI report. She explained that my pain does not seem to come from a minor meniscus tear but from a swelling that may have a different cause or may go away with some anti-inflammatory.
What went well
- Office environment
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
9 others found this helpful
Helpful
Apr 28, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
After 3 visits had to wait 5 days for a return telephone call,,,had to make appt for a phone call!!!!dr did not recommend anti-inflammatory and took some for another ailment and eliminated my pain in my knee.
What went well
- Office environment
- Wait times
What could be improved
- Difficult to schedule appointment
- Appointment was rushed
- Didn't trust the provider's decisions
2 others found this helpful
Helpful
Jan 15, 2018
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Dr. McCarthy is an excellent surgeon who genuinely cares about her patients. I went to her 3 weeks after a traumatic injury to my knee and I had already seen 3 other surgeons. She sat with me for a long time (and through many tears), explained exactly what happened and how we were going to fix it. Her unrivaled bedside manner made such a difference. I had a very successful surgery and recovery. Dr, McCarthy and her whole staff at HSS checked in on me multiple times and are always available!
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
9 others found this helpful
Helpful
New York – Nov 30, 2017
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
She was excellent. She made me feel comfortable with the surgery. The surgery experience at HSS was superb as was Dr. McCarthy! I recommend her to everyone.
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
8 others found this helpful
Helpful
New York, NY – Sep 03, 2016
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Awesome experience. I tore my meniscus, ACL, and MCL. It was a long road to recovery, but Dr. McCarthy explained that it would be long from the beginning but that I would get back to soccer. I am so grateful! I recommend her to everyone!
What went well
- Office environment
- Appointment scheduling
- Listened & answered questions
- Explained conditions well
- Staff friendliness
- Appointment wasn't rushed
- Trusted the provider's decisions
- Wait times
What could be improved
No results
7 others found this helpful
Helpful
Stamford, CT – Aug 20, 2016
Post a ResponseAre you Dr. McCarthy?
Leave a review
How was your experience with Dr. McCarthy?Overall Patient Satisfaction
20responses
Likelihood of recommending Dr. McCarthy to family and friends is 4.4 out of 5
About Me
biography
Dr. Moira M. McCarthy is an orthopedic surgeon on the Sports Medicine and Shoulder Service at Hospital for Special Surgery. She specializes in the care of knee and shoulder injuries in active patients. Her clinical interests include...read moreOrthopedic Surgery
Hip & Knee Orthopedics
Orthopedic Shoulder & Elbow Surgery
Orthopedic Sports Medicine
Reconstructive Orthopedic Surgery
Pediatric Orthopedic Surgery
*Healthgrades does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.
Princeton University
Undergraduate SchoolSports Medicine And Shoulder Surgery Fellowship - Hss
2014Hospital For S
Fellowship Hospital, 2014Hospital For Special Surgery
Internship Hospital, 2009Columbia University Vagelos College Of Physicians And Surgeons
Medical School, 2008
American Board of Medical Specialties®
American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery®
-
Orthopaedic Sports Medicine
-
Orthopedic Surgery
For detailed information about any of the below board actions, please search for the provider's records on the linked state licensing board or the Federation of State Medical Boards. To learn more about the difference between these sources, please refer to our FAQs.
Healthgrades has not received any data indicating a board action exists for this provider.
Healthgrades receives board action history for physicians and physician assistants. The information displayed here is sourced from independent information providers, such as state board websites, and may not be the most up-to-date information. Healthgrades makes no representations with respect to the accuracy of any information provided here and assumes no responsibility or liability for such information.
Learn more about medical license public record checkHealthgrades Tips for Getting Orthopedic Care
Locations
Practice
Hospital for Special Surgery535 E 70th St New York, NY 10021
Ip Ct LLC1 Blachley Rd Stamford, CT 06902
David Mayman MD PC523 E 72nd St New York, NY 10021
Stamford Health1 Hospital Plz Stamford, CT 06902
Affiliated Hospitals
- Recipient of 4
hospital awardsView all patient feedbackHow patients felt about the care they received at this hospital.
85%Patients said they were given information about recovering at home1% higher than the national average
77%Patients said that doctors always listened to them and explained things well1% higher than the national average
Learn more about how Healthgrades measures Hospital Quality
Compare Providers
Providers shown based on Dr. McCarthy's location and specialty. Show more Orthopedic Surgeons.