Dr. Andrew Stith, MD

Very poor! He spent at best 5 minutes in the exam room, (after I sat waiting for at least 15 minutes), never even examined or manipulated my broken ankle, and showed me MRI images that do not even appear to be my own. I received my MRI Report and images the following day from Health Images, and what Dr. Stith showed me does NOT in any way address the incomplete fracture of my tibia or the avulsed posterior tibial tendon that the MRI report shows. He diagnosed it as a sprain and gave me exercises when the radiologist said it should be casted, or in the least case, a boot. I have a lame lace-up brace from OCR that does nearly nothing. I am very disappointed, discouraged from following up and cancelled my future appointments with him. Really poor examination! I am also a doctor who would never treat my patients in such a manner. Zero stars!

I had an appointment with Dr Stith a month ago about my ankle swelling periodically and I really liked him. Very knowledgeable and looked at my X-Rays and gave me a cortisone shot that worked great for one month. He told me- if it ever swells up again to come down and he would see me. I happened to be in Greeley today and it swells up so I went down and did not see me. When a doctor tells me what to do I do it. When a person does not follow through with their word that is very disappointing to a person like me. If he wasn’t there then I’m fine with it. It would have taken literally 5 minutes to look at it and give me his opinion which I value. I’m very frustrated and disappointed in him- a doctor tells me what to do and literally a month later goes back on his word. I kept hearing- he doesn’t take walk ins. I realize that- I’m here because he told me to come down as soon as it swells.

You don't ever have to wait to be seen.

Dr. Stith took the time to explain my injury and set realistic expectations for recovery and rehab. He was patient to answer all of my questions at every visit. The repair is a complete success. I highly recommend Dr. Stith.

Excellent work by Dr. Stith prior to, during, and after the surgery. He is an attentive, patient listener, takes the necessary time to answer questions, clear on the diagnosis, treatment options and risks (surgery vs. non-surgical), next steps, and recovery outlook. He was available for the initial appointment 2 days after my injury, and I had a surgery 5 days later. Surgery went well, no complications. I would highly recommend Dr. Stith to all patients.

Dr.Stith completed a complicated surgery and followed up with extensive therapy to return me to a healthy condition I hadn't experienced in years. His expertise and kindness were most appreciated!

Dr. Stith is a very kind and caring doctor who listens to your concerns and then takes the time to explain how to correct the problem. He is a highly trained specialist in the care of the ankle and foot. I’ve had excellent results from the surgery performed by him.

Dr Stith effectively diagnosed my problem, and efficiently offered solutions. The treatment is working, and I am following his recommendations, I know that I can seek further assistance should I need. He has a very proactive team of support individuals, who make sure there is a comprehensive treatment environment.

He repaired what many refused to do. The issues are extensive and will take time to heal. This year I accepted surgery for ankle replacement and more reconstruction. This surgery is the 2nd time I've been his patient. I would recommend his services.

Dr Stith and his staff are always kind, patient and thorough. I'm happy that he's part of my orthopedic care!

Dr. Stith recognized and successfully repaired the abnormality in my foot that was causing my discomfort. He was knowledgeable, patient with my concerns and questions, and performed the surgery skillfully. I wish I would have seen him sooner!

Very knowledgeable about the ankle and discusses all options thoroughly. Efficient and personable. Thanks doc stith

My husband and I both saw Dr. Stith in December with different foot problems. My issue required surgery, which went well. Dr. Stith showed my husband a quick non surgical method to relieve his chronic foot pain. I am fully recovered from my foot surgery with great results. My husband uses the method shown to him by Dr Stith to treat his foot pain. It has now been over two months since he has had the chronic foot pain that has plagued him for years. We both recommend Dr. Stith!

I saw Dr. Stith for the first time last week at the Greeley clinic site. Check in was quick as was the start of my appointment. I found all staff from the desk, X-ray technicians, medical assistant to be kind, efficient and courteous professionals. Dr Stith saw me at our appointed time, listened to my answers to his questions and completely answered mine. At this point, I am hopeful I will not have the opportunity to evaluate him as a surgeon, but I am very confident that if it comes to that I am in very good hands. I found him to be compassionate, professional and very positive.